I came across this article about the singer Roland Orzabal from the ’80s group Tears For Fears. It’s ostensibly an article about the singer’s new autobiography, written by someone who is clearly a big fan of the group.

The article’s author, Phil Christman, goes into detail on the band’s songs, far beyond the retro hits that most people (like me) know, and mixes in a lot of personal observations on what’s in the book. The article isn’t really a review of the book as much as it is an opportunity for the writer to talk about his personal history with the music.

What I really found interesting, though, wasn’t Tears For Fears, or the book, or even the article. It was the reactions to the article on the news compilation site Metafilter. People said it was “fabulous” and “had (them) howling.” A few people talked about enjoying Tears For Fears albums, but most of the comments were about the article, not the book or the music, which of course inspired the whole thing in the first place.

I read the article, but I didn’t find it “fabulous” nor did it have me “howling.” It was witty, but nothing special. The article didn’t make me want to read the book (will I read it anyway? Maybe; I enjoy ’80s music), but it did get me thinking about how varied opinions can be.

Name a work of art — no, name simply something that has been created, even if it’s just an app for use at work, or a single-sheet flyer promoting a product — and you’ll find someone who loves it (maybe just its creator, and hopefully a lot of other people) and someone who dislikes it, for whatever reason. I even found someone who didn’t like the movie “E.T.”!

Maybe it’s just easier to be a critic. Maybe a person genuinely likes the thing that has been created, and appreciates the work that went into it, but doesn’t see any value in it to them, which affects their opinion of the whole project. Maybe they would enjoy it if they experienced it on a different day. It could be any of those. It could be all of them.

But seeing such a variety of opinions tells me that it’s OK to create, even if there are people out there who won’t like it, whether that’s a random person online, or a client for your work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *